Elevaire Systems
← Back to Insights
Compliance & Insurancecompliancesecurity leadershipFTC Safeguards Rule

The FTC Safeguards Rule: Does It Apply to Your Business?

Elevaire Systems·

A 40-person tax and bookkeeping practice renews its preparers' IRS credentials in the fall, and each preparer checks a box acknowledging that the firm is required to have a written information security plan. Nobody at the firm is sure where that plan is, or who wrote it. The checkbox points to a federal rule most small businesses assume only applies to banks: the FTC Safeguards Rule.

The rule's reach is much wider than its reputation. This post covers who it applies to, what it requires, where growing companies fall short, and how to get compliant.

What the Safeguards Rule is

The Safeguards Rule (16 CFR Part 314) comes from the Gramm-Leach-Bliley Act. It requires "financial institutions" under the Federal Trade Commission's jurisdiction to run an information security program that protects their customers' information. Banks, credit unions and SEC-registered investment advisers answer to their own regulators. The FTC's version covers the much larger group of non-bank businesses that handle consumer financial information.

The FTC rewrote the rule in a final rule published in December 2021, adding specific controls such as multi-factor authentication, encryption and a named person in charge of the program. Most of those new requirements took effect on June 9, 2023, after the FTC extended the original deadline. A second amendment, published in the Federal Register in November 2023, added a breach reporting duty that took effect on May 13, 2024.

Who it applies to (more businesses than you would expect)

The rule covers businesses that are "significantly engaged" in financial activities, or in activities incidental to them. There is no revenue or headcount threshold. A five-person shop can be covered just as much as a 200-person one.

The FTC's own compliance guide for businesses and the rule text give examples of covered businesses, including:

  • Mortgage lenders and mortgage brokers
  • Payday lenders, finance companies and other non-bank lenders
  • Most auto dealers that arrange financing or leasing for customers
  • Tax preparation firms
  • Collection agencies
  • Credit counselors and other financial advisers not regulated by another agency
  • Check cashers and wire transfer services
  • "Finders," a category added in 2021 for businesses that bring together buyers and sellers of a financial product and are more than occasionally involved with consumers

Two details decide a lot of edge cases. First, a business that does both financial and non-financial work is still covered if the financial activity is significant. The FTC's guidance for auto dealers is a good illustration: a dealer that arranges financing or leasing for customers is generally covered, even though most of its business is selling cars. Second, the rule protects information about consumers, meaning individuals who get a financial product or service for personal, family or household purposes. A lender that only serves businesses has a different analysis than one that serves households.

Accounting firms land in scope through tax preparation. The IRS has said repeatedly that federal law, through the Safeguards Rule, requires paid tax preparers to create and maintain a written information security plan, and its Publication 4557 walks through what that plan should contain. The IRS and its Security Summit partners also publish a free WISP template (Publication 5708) aimed at smaller practices.

If you recognized your business in that list, assume you are covered until a lawyer tells you otherwise.

What the rule actually requires

The amended rule is specific. The core elements, in plain language:

  1. Name a Qualified Individual. One person oversees and enforces the security program. That person can be an employee, or can work for an affiliate or a service provider such as a virtual CISO. The business stays responsible either way.
  2. Do a written risk assessment. Identify where customer information lives, what could go wrong, and how well current safeguards hold up. Repeat it periodically.
  3. Put safeguards in place based on that assessment. The rule names several:
    • Access controls, so people only see the customer information they need
    • An inventory of the data, devices, systems and facilities involved
    • Encryption of customer information at rest and in transit over external networks
    • Multi-factor authentication for anyone accessing an information system that holds customer information
    • Secure disposal of customer information no later than two years after it was last used, unless there is a legitimate business or legal reason to keep it
    • Change management, plus monitoring and logging of user activity
  4. Test and monitor. Either continuous monitoring, or annual penetration testing plus vulnerability assessments at least every six months.
  5. Train staff on security awareness, and make sure security personnel stay current.
  6. Oversee service providers. Choose vendors that can protect the data, require it in the contract, and check on them periodically.
  7. Keep the program current as the business, its systems and its risks change.
  8. Write an incident response plan covering goals, roles, communications, remediation and documentation.
  9. Report to leadership. The Qualified Individual reports in writing at least once a year to the board or, if there is no board, a senior officer, covering the program's status and material risks.

On top of those, the 2024 amendment requires a covered business to notify the FTC as soon as possible, and no later than 30 days after discovery, when unencrypted customer information about 500 or more consumers is acquired without authorization. The FTC has said it intends to make those reports public.

The small-business exemption, and what it does not cover

Businesses that maintain customer information on fewer than 5,000 consumers get a partial break. Section 314.6 exempts them from four items. Everything else still applies.

RequirementFewer than 5,000 consumers5,000 or more consumers
Qualified IndividualRequiredRequired
Written risk assessmentExemptRequired
MFA, encryption, access controlsRequiredRequired
Continuous monitoring or pen testingExemptRequired
Staff training and vendor oversightRequiredRequired
Written incident response planExemptRequired
Annual written report to leadershipExemptRequired
FTC notice for 500+ consumer breachRequiredRequired

The count is consumers whose information you keep, not customers you served this year. A tax practice that has kept a decade of returns can cross 5,000 without noticing. The exemption also says nothing about being exempt from the controls themselves. A 3,000-client firm still needs MFA, encryption, a named owner, training and vendor oversight.

Where growing companies usually fall short

No named owner. The office manager handles "IT stuff," the outside IT provider handles the network, and nobody is formally the Qualified Individual. When a client, examiner or insurer asks who runs the security program, there is no clean answer.

MFA with holes. Email has multi-factor sign-in, but the tax software, the loan origination system, the document portal or the shared admin account does not. The rule covers any system holding customer information.

Old data nobody uses. Closed loan files and prior-year returns sit on a file share indefinitely. The two-year disposal requirement turns that habit into a compliance gap.

Vendors taken on trust. Payroll, e-signature, document storage and CRM vendors all touch customer data. The rule expects you to check, and to put the expectation in the contract. In a 2020 case, the FTC alleged that a mortgage analytics company violated the Safeguards Rule by failing to oversee a vendor that left mortgage files exposed online without a password or encryption. The settlement required the company to strengthen its program and submit to independent assessments every two years.

A plan that exists only in a drawer. A template filled in once and never revisited does not show that anyone is running a program.

What a realistic path to compliance looks like

For a 25 to 200 person business, this usually takes a few months, not years. A typical sequence:

  1. Confirm scope (weeks 1 to 2). Decide, with counsel if needed, whether the business is covered and roughly how many consumers' records it holds. That number decides whether the exemption applies.
  2. Name the Qualified Individual and inventory the data (weeks 2 to 4). List every system, device and vendor that touches customer information.
  3. Close the control gaps (months 1 to 3). MFA everywhere it is required, encryption on laptops and storage, tightened access, a disposal schedule, and monitoring in place.
  4. Write it down (months 2 to 3). The risk assessment, the information security plan, vendor reviews and, if required, the incident response plan.
  5. Set the cadence (ongoing). Training, vulnerability scanning or monitoring, vendor check-ins, and the annual report to leadership.

Most of the technical work in step 3 is the same work cyber insurers and client security questionnaires already ask about.

Example engagement: a 50-person mortgage brokerage learns from its warehouse lender that it needs to show a Safeguards Rule program. Elevaire would serve as or support the Qualified Individual through its virtual CISO service, inventory where borrower files live, turn on MFA for the loan origination system and document portal, set a disposal schedule for closed files, review the brokerage's key vendors, and produce the written risk assessment, incident response plan and first annual report. Elevaire Managed Security would then handle the ongoing monitoring, vulnerability scanning and staff training the rule expects, alongside the brokerage's existing IT provider.

How Elevaire fits

The rule asks for two things a growing business rarely has in-house: a senior owner for the program, and someone running the day-to-day controls. Elevaire's virtual CISO covers the first: risk assessment, policies, vendor reviews and the annual report. Elevaire Managed Security covers the second: MFA and access hardening, device encryption, email security, training, vulnerability scanning and monitoring. For a defined project, compliance readiness work maps the rule to what is already in place and closes the gaps. None of this replaces your current IT provider; Elevaire works alongside them.

Frequently Asked Questions

Does the FTC Safeguards Rule apply to small businesses?

Yes, if the business is significantly engaged in financial activities such as lending, tax preparation, collections or arranging financing. There is no revenue or employee threshold. Businesses holding information on fewer than 5,000 consumers are exempt from four requirements, but still need a Qualified Individual, MFA, encryption, training and vendor oversight.

Do accounting firms and tax preparers have to follow the Safeguards Rule?

The IRS states that paid tax preparers are required by federal law to have a written information security plan, and it points to the Safeguards Rule as the source. IRS Publication 4557 explains the requirements, and Publication 5708 provides a template. Firms that do tax work should treat the rule as applying to them.

What does Safeguards Rule compliance cost?

It depends mostly on how many controls are already in place. Elevaire handles the ongoing work for predictable monthly pricing with no hourly billing, and quotes compliance readiness projects up front.

Can our existing IT provider handle Safeguards Rule compliance?

Your IT provider likely handles parts of it, such as patching and backups. The rule also requires a named Qualified Individual, written risk assessments, vendor oversight and annual reporting, which many IT providers do not offer. Elevaire works alongside your current provider to cover the security leadership and monitoring pieces rather than replacing them.

What happens if we have a data breach under the Safeguards Rule?

If unencrypted customer information about 500 or more consumers is acquired without authorization, you must notify the FTC no later than 30 days after discovering it. State breach notification laws may also require notice to affected customers. A written incident response plan makes those deadlines much easier to meet.

How do we get started with the Safeguards Rule?

Confirm whether you are covered and roughly how many consumers' records you keep. Then name a Qualified Individual and inventory where customer information lives. A gap assessment against the rule shows what to fix first, usually MFA coverage, encryption and data disposal.

About Elevaire Systems

Elevaire Systems is a managed security services provider for growing companies. We run your security tools and vendors, watch for threats and stop attacks for one predictable monthly price, with virtual CISO leadership and compliance readiness when you need more.

See Where Your Security Stands

Take the free 3-minute scorecard for your top security risks, or book a 30-minute Risk Snapshot to talk it through.